Wednesday, January 18, 2006

The Meaning of Words

My thoughts on the meaning of words influenced by Beethoven's Last Night. (I use * to identify it)

I wonder, if one was to become deaf, if they would begin to think and feel in music rather than in mental dialogue. I tend to feel and think with words, but I wonder if I could do so with music? "It's Cold", "What a beautiful tree", "this room smells." -all things we use words to describe. Yet I continue to wonder, could you use music to convey all these thoughts? And more?

*NO NEED FOR WORDS FOR IN THE DARK
ALL WORDS HAVE LONG SINCE LOST THEIR MEANING


If a great musician became deaf, such as the great Beethoven, would he see things in music? Sonatas and Fugues and Funeral Marches? Would words lose meaning and would he live his life, a fantastical musical score hiding behind every chore, meal, walk in the park? Would you still hear voices at all...

*WHAT GOOD THIS DEAFNESS
THAT MY WHOLE LIFE I HAVE DREAD
WHAT GOOD THIS DEAFNESS
WITH THESE VOICES IN MY HEAD


The words we use arn't truly the deepest meaning after all, right? We use words to describe thoughts, feelings, actions, etc. To pass on meaning from one person to the next. So words are merely a filter that meaning passes through.
If I saw a beautiful sunset, and later tried to describe it to someone, I have the picture of the sunset in my mind. No no, not a picture, the theme. So I have the "theme" of the sunset in mind, what it looked like, what it felt like to look upon, etc. I merely use words to try to convey the meaning. Words are simply a filter that meaning has to pass through to communicate.
-But it isn't the only way. I could create a painting of the sunset, but especially coming from me it would never capture the Meaning, the Theme, of the Real Sunset.

Yet, our mind seems to use words doesn't it? For, when we begin to comprehend complicated subjects, our mind rearranges words in our mind until the meaning, or theme, of what is being explained matches the meaning in our mind.
However, if we could get past using words as our primary form of communication... for words are merely a "filter" that we use to communicate meaning, -would it be possible to take up another form of conveying meaning? Themes?

-Could we use music to convey meaning, a complete and unfiltered theme? Words are only tools for describing ideas and themes, can't music be the same? If not more?

*BUT IN THE NIGHT
THE DARKNESS BREATHES
IF HE WILLS IT TO BE


Music can infact convey emotion, virtue, and meaning. We try to use words to describe it, or pictures to understand, but maybe it's the meaning that we should really take away from music.
If a great musician was deaf, uninhibited by the filtered down words.. is it possible that he could create more meaningful music than anyone? And even if he did use words, they would be less meaningful to him, therefore he could quite possible use them more effectively in the music.
We often hear music in different languages, sometimes the words are intentionally unintelligible. -Yet, because of this, the meaning is able to come through unfiltered. Yes?

Alas... a deaf musician is unable to hear his music. What great difficulty he would have, getting the theme from his head to the world around him. And, if this musician fell in love, what greater difficulty would he have communicating love.

*Beethoven believes that if Theresa were to have discovered that he was becoming deaf she would most certainly have left him. Before this could happen, he ended their relationship refusing to ever see her again.

Yet, even with the power of music, are words necessary to our existence as humans?

*Theresa: TRY
I HAVE TRIED
TO PRETEND THAT I DON'T CARE
BUT THEN
SLEEP ARRIVES
AND IN EVERY DREAM I FIND YOU THERE


*Theresa is watching Beethoven through the window. She can see him slumped over the piano. She does not understand why he has driven her out of his life. She knows that something is terribly wrong but has no idea what it is. Nothing that he could tell her would affect her love for him, but Beethoven cannot believe this.

-Are we so connected to language that existing without it is painful? -Yes. We are. Even though it is filtered, it is the most practical and functional means of communication. For even the simple minded, or those who arn't skilled in an art, can use words with meaning.
-if a musician was deaf, with all his difficulty.. what would his life of pain be worth?

Theresa: BUT I DON'T WANT THE PAST TO BE MY LIFE
AND I DON'T WANT TO LIVE INSIDE THE NIGHT
BUT I DON'T WANT TO SEE YOUR SHADOW FADE
SO I SLEEP AND I DREAM
THOUGH I DON'T UNDERSTAND IT


*Beethoven realizes that Theresa never would have cared about his deafness and is crushed as he realizes what might have been. To ease the pain of his regret, Fate then shows him glimpses of the future and the countless musicians who will be inspired by, and build upon the legacy of his music. She then allows him a final vision; a vision in which he improvises with musicians from the past by whom he was inspired , as well as musicians from the future, who will be inspired by him.

Yet, would this pain, this suffering, and this lack of words... create someone with a unique view of life. -unusually, and painfully, seperated from the world?

*At the end of this last minute review of his life, he now realizes that the removal of what he considers the most painful moments of his life also removes the inspiration for what he considers his finest work. Change one thing and he changes it all.

So, in conclusion... Beethoven went through a lot. But his trials created an amazing, gifted person with the ability to create unique, inspired music.

-Okay, so does all my philosophy on "words are filters" mean anything in the end? Hmm... I'm unsure. I do think that words are a filter for meaning. Additionally, I do think that music has the ability to convey a purer form of meaning.

For music is a pure theme, without words to muddle it's meaning. So in theory, a song without words could convey more meaning than one full of them.

Therefore, in conclusion: Beethoven is the freaking man.

4 comments:

Gene Paul said...

words are weird, aren't they? Could you have even expressed those philosophical ideas without words? But then, what exactly is the necessity of even thinking of those philosophical quandaries? Why not just accept that we use words to communicate, and try to use them the best we can? (can you tell I've thought about this too?)

There's a movie I watched a while ago, called "Waking Life." It's basically just a big long philosophical treatise, but there are some awesome ideas floated out there, and I like it because the ideas are put out there to think about - not with any authority or purpose. But the idea about words and inherent meaning is one that is mentioned. And it's animated in such a beautiful manner.... You'd have to see it to understand what I mean.

Anyway, I'll stop wasting my words.

Isaac Mahomie said...

Hey! someone responded! Yes!!
-lol, good points. Words are the superior form of communication, yet the strong impact of Art interests me. guess I was just taking my mind for a mental jog.

"Waking Life", I'll have to give it a watch. Got any other philosophical movies to recommend? I just watched a German film, "Run Lola Run." Interesting, but not overly philosophical.

Gene Paul said...

Run Lola Run rocks! I like the synthesis of music and action in that movie, as well as the form of storytelling.

Speaking of good storytelling, watch "Memento" - unique way to tell a story. Not philosophical, just entertaining.

Um, let's see, philosophical movies... "Pi" is interesting, but it's not really philosophical in the way that any idea is being put forth, it's more just using a philosophy to tell a story - but an interesting one. Kind of disturbing, though. Um, Fight Club is actually philosophical, though in a different way than what we're talking about - it's actually kind of a socialist/absurdist philosophy.

Those are really all I can think of right now. Most of the philosophy I have absorbed has been from books. It's usually very hard to make a philosophical movie that is really good, because it gets bogged down in the very thing it's trying to express.

Oh, apparently "I Heart Huckabees" is philosophical in some way, but I haven't seen it, so I have no idea.

Isaac Mahomie said...

I've seen Fight Club, and Memento. Memento was great, I love that movie.