Saturday, July 15, 2006

Opinions

Everyone is so set in having their own opinion.

Which is good, most of the time. We're supposed to have our own opinions, we're supposed to observe and develop conclusions and solutions.
However, if you don't know what your talking about, your opinion doesn't matter.

I mean, really! If you haven't spent time observing and studying, your opinion isn't supported by fact!
If you don't know what your talking about, your opinion on the subject carries no weight.

13 comments:

Sarah said...

*Cough* Hypocrite...*cough-hack-cough* i.e. *cough* "The Chronicles of Narnia is Undeniably Superior to Harry Potter" *cough-cough* Talk about unfounded opinions... *cooooooough-hack-hack*

Sarah said...

Well, then if you have READ both series, then your opinion is justified and I bear you no ill will.

Isaac Mahomie said...

C.S. Lewis is amazing, you can't beat him.

Sorry. Aslan is a way better Jesus than any Harry Potter character could be.

Isaac Mahomie said...

-but, this post has nothing to do with a subject as trivial as Harry Potter

Sarah said...

I'm not saying Harry Potter is Jesus. Nothing in Harry Potter is Jesus. Don't be stupid. And stop twisting what I said. I am saying that maybe you should read the Harry Potter series before you state any sort of opinion between the two.

Especially before you post things like this entry.

Until you have read the Harry Potter series, your opinion on this subject, in your own words, carries no weight.

Sarah said...

-No it doesn't but your blog post brought to mind your opinion of both Harry Potter and Chronicles of Narnia and your Facebook group about the two.

...And how you have not READ Harry Potter, therefore you should not make comments, or groups or whatever about it, until you have done something (i.e. read the series) to support your opinion either way.

The subject of Harry Potter vs. Chronicles of Narnia may be trivial. But hypocrisy it not.

Isaac Mahomie said...

How many people will be in heaven because of J.K. Rowling.

Sarah said...

That is not relavent to what we are debating.

1. You haven't read Harry Potter.

2. By your own blog post, you are being hypocritical in stating, through the Facebook group YOU started, that Chronicles of Narnia is superior to the Harry Potter series.

I don't care about the strong Christian allegories put in Chronicles of Narnia. I'm talking about comparing two very strong pieces of work, baised on writing, character development and plot/subplot.

Yes, the Narnia series is amazing. Yes, it's an outstanding piece of Christian liturature. But why does everything have to be compared and analyzed through a Christian perspective and compared negatively to other books who, although in the same genre, are not written for the same purpose?

You haven't read the books. Period. You do not have a full idea of what you're talking about. When you've read the series, can give me page numbers and quote passages from the books that you have problems with, THEN maybe we can accurately discuss this topic, as THEN your opinion will then carry weight.

*tangent* Thinking about what you said about the musical "Wicked." Why does it matter that you don't think it has strong/good morals? There are defianetly worse musicals/plays out there. (When I saw Sweeney Todd, they had a rape scene. On STAGE! NOT something I needed to see.) Why not just do something for the pure enjoyment of it? Now, before you write a response to that---stop. By that comment I don't intend for you to do things that are sinful, against the law, or harmful to yourself or others. But why not just sit back for once and enjoy something without critisizing it, or being bent on disliking it?

Anonymous said...

Ok, this is just getting dumb. First of all you both have good points. Sarah is correct in the fact that you shouldn't judge something that you have never read yourself, othwerwise your argument is only half there anyway. However Isaac's comment about people being in heaven has much releavence. In the end God will destroy all that is and make a new heaven and a new earth for us to live in. At that point all that will have relevance is people that were able to come to Christ (well, and christ himself of course). So it is indeed a valid point. In case anyone really wants to know, I do personally like Narnia better. I have read the Harry Potter books (at least through the 4th anyway). they were good and worth reading but I still like Narnia better.
Anyway the moral of this story is facebook clubs are all based on opinions. There are billions of different clubs and all of them trying to exalt their own opinion from their own point of view. There is really no point in arguing over them. At least if your looking at them in a broad sense anyway

Heather said...

Dear Chris,
THANK YOU!

Dear Sarah,
You are right. Way to beat him at his own game.

Dear Isaac,
Shut up.

And as far as the original blog post goes, well you're basically right; the only problem with that is, who gets to decide when the person is informed enough about said subject to hold an opinion that counts, eh? And even if one is a literal expert on the topic at hand, pure knowledge isn't the only thing to be concerned with. For one, chances are there are at least a few pieces of information one could still stand to learn about said issue, and for two, there is NEVER a good reason to let your own knowledge--no matter how vast--lead to arrogance. No matter how smart you are compared to the other person, even if they do have a completely unfounded opinion and you're practically a guru, for heaven's sake don't converse with them as if you were God Almighty and they merely a lowly spider who could never dream of understanding. It's fucking annoying, and no one is ever going to listen to you if you come across that way.

Apanda said...

Poor Isaac, you really didn't want it to go this way, did you?

samharris32 said...

heather, i dont know you, but i agree with you... and with sarah... i just hope youre LISTNING to these people that you love isaac... because youre sure not listning on the forums!

Isaac Mahomie said...

Sarah, from your side of the argument, you are completely right."
But from my side of the argument, I'm right.

What you are doing is arguing from a relative standpoint, but I am taking the entire picture into view.

But first....
I DO know a few thing's about Harry Potter.

First off, I have yet to have multiple people whose opinion I trust to say that they like it more than Narnia. (and I mean REALLY like it, not like "I'm reading this book and it's so great. Like after looking back on it, you still view it higher.)
2nd off, even though movies arn't fair, I've seen 3 Harry Potter movies, and I didn't find it appealing. The stakes arn't high enough, I don't like Harry's plot choices, and I don't find the setting to be that interesting in the first place. I've read quotes, reviews on Potter.... the setting never really appealed to me.
And I know you should never judge a book by it's movie, but the single Narnia movie was freaking amazing, three Potter's left me slightly impressed.

I have decided that it's not worth spending a year of my life reading Harry Potter. I have many, many, many other thing's that I want to read.

So, really, I do know something about it.

And really, if your going to just compare story to story, it's all relative anyway! Different people like different thing's!
If I created a facebook group that said "chocolate ice-cream is undeniably superior to butterscotch." I don't think you'd get up in my face and say "have you REALLY tasted EVERY kind of butterscotch there is to taste?"

I feel like your zooming in on a small part of the comparison, the physical book side by side. But I'm zooming out to look at the big picture, and it's entire impact on others.

Now, for the Christian standpoint.
-the main focus of the facebook group is that C.S. Lewis will always be superior to JK Rowling. C.S. Lewis is a great writer and theologian, he has done so many thing's for the good of humanity in the name of Christ. He has written everything from children's books to studies in theology.

Harry Potter has a magic theme, like Chronicles of Narnia, but extremely different. Hogwarts does all kinds of magical hocus pocus, which isn't harmful unless placed in the wrong child's hands, basically harmless.
Yet in Narnia, the "Deep Magic" reflects a system of order and Justice. This magic is never explained or given opportunity to become dangerous. Plus, it carries God's sacrifice theme, and provides pages and pages of Biblical/spiritual references.
So Harry Potter's sorcery = mostly harmless
Narnia's = Spiritually beneficial.

In fact, all of Narnia is abundant with food for the mind to feed on, pointing our souls straight towards the Bible. Instead of ignoring authority and somehow coming out okay everytime, Lewis cleverly incorporates Biblical principles to teach children (and adults) real life lessons, while still telling an incredible story.

In The Silver Chair, Lewis cleverly wove in the Cavern's of Socrates to the Green Witch's lies. I never fully understood that part when I was younger, but now that I'm older (And went through the CWC class) I see how ingenious Lewis was to use this to teach us a lesson about the faith it takes to be a Christian. And who can ever forget Puddleglum's response! May all Christians be that clear-headed!

Aslan says "I am in your world too, but I am known by a different name there."
Last of all, Aslan secretely bears the name of Christ. In Prince Caspian, Lucy says "Aslan! Your so much bigger than I remembered!"
Aslan replies along the lines of: "The more you come to know me, the bigger I will seem to you"

This carries the lesson that the more we know Christ, the more we will truly understand the depth of His Glory, and He will become even more personal to us.
Reading about Aslan is a clever examination and re-application of the character of Christ, able to teach multiple generations on the complexity of God's character.
Aslan has swallowed man, women, boys and girls. Yet he also goes through incredible self-sacrifice for others, loving his family and taking care of his land.
The children all love and respect Aslan, and when they do not, they fall upon unfortune. (See my Edmund post) When examining the character of Aslan, we are really learning about Christ.

These are PRICELESS lessons that can be learned as children, and relearned over and over again. Every time I read the Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, I pick up a new spiritual application. I don't even have to go looking for it it just pops out at me. (I've read it like 12 times now) C.S. Lewis, a master of fantasy, spirituality, and storytelling, has packed his books with spiritual food.

So in the end: Yeah, I haven't sat down and actually read Harry Potter. You win the relative argument, hands down.
But as far as comparing the generational positive impact, The Chronicles of Narnia is breathtaking.