Sunday, September 24, 2006

Star Wars Episode I

So I'm listening to Weird Al, "The Saga Begins."

"Do you see him hitting on the queen
Though he's just 9 and she's 14,
Yeah, he's probably gonna marry her someday."

This started some very interesting questions about the plot of Episode I... consider this:

In Episode II, Padme explains that she was ELECTED to the position of "Queen" and finished her term, which is when the new Queen asked Padme to become a Senator.

First of all, Padme Amidala is her real name. When she's pretending to be an escort, and her bodyguard/decoy/lookalike (Kiera Knightly) is pretending to be the Queen, she goes by Padme. Was the Trade Federation so stupid that they didn't bother to find out the Queen's real name? The Jedi either? They travelled around with Padme, and didn't seem to figure it out. You know how easy it is to dig up dirt on politicians? How ridiculous is that?

Second, who lets Kiera Knightly rule the kingdom in your place? Was Padme crazy!? She gives in to torture!

Third, and most importantly... Who elects a 14 year old girl to be the Queen of their entire planet!? Are the people on Naboo so stupid and helpless that the most competant person they can find is a girl who isn't even done with puberty yet!? You might as well have a D-20 making your decisions! She couldn't even ally with the gungans before the whole Trade Federation thing started... The gungans!!! A bunch of frog people! WHO MADE JAR JAR BINKS A GENERAL!!!! What is up with this planet!?!?
The only offworlder who even likes Naboo is Anakin! Ah!

-Sometimes, I really hate George Lucas.

6 comments:

Heather said...

In our culture, 14 year olds are a lot less mature than in other cultures. She had political training and what not. Yeah, you've got a point, she was only 14...but you also have to look at the context a bit.

If you were truly a Star Wars nerd you'd know that Keira Knightley's character happened to be named Padme too. Duh. When Queen Amidala was pretending to be her handmaiden, it makes sense that she would go by her handmaiden's name. Padme the non-queen just had a different last name. It was French-ish and started with an N, and if I tried to spell it I would undoubtedly fail horribly. If you were the king of somewhere and you switched places with your sidekick who was also named Isaac, you would still run around going by Isaac...not rocket science.

And you have a bias against girls and Keira Knightley, but that doesn't make George Lucas a bad screenwriter. Lots of other things make him a bad screenwriter.

And of course, if the Nabooites (?) had been perfect, we wouldn't have a story now would we? It's not like this scenario is unrealistic, lots of crazy crap happens in the world. I wonder what would happen to you if you took an anthropology class.

Isaac Mahomie said...

Relativist.

Anonymous said...

I wonder if everyone knows that "frontal lobes" are part of the brain and don't refer to other anatomical structures that might be less than fully developed on a 14-year-old girl.

Isaac Mahomie said...

-I know it's unlikely, but we were actually talking about the brain.

Heather said...

HAHA! Anonymous, whoever you are...I love you.

Anonymous said...

There is also the fact that she was dumb enough to like a nine year old. I mean, really, if you were to marry some kid thats 5 years younger than you when you are like 22 tops, how could you be mature enough the be Queen. I mean not just some government person but QUEEN! The whole planet was crazy like "woops thisa way" and "thaysa be goin toa secret place". By the way, the Jedi would have sensed that she wasn't the Queen. I mean "sense motive" is wisdom and obi has like 16-18 wisdom, duh! and george lucas is a bad screenwriter "My love cant save you Padme! Only my new powers can do tha!" LAME!!! Well, I have to let the keyboard cool down. Point proven.

Simeownd