[Directed at you, Isaac, since I am not particularly concerned with Laura's need to defend her reasons for being intrigued; I am, however, fairly certain that a claim like the one you just made requires some legitimate backing up].
Because smoking cigarettes is so overwhelmingly bad. The health issues vastly outweigh the benefits. In the American midwest, I find it highly improbable that a Christian could escape conviction on the issue.
Ahem. Smoking is bad for your health, but so is many other things. Such as fast food and staying in the sun for too long a time. None of these you have labelled "sins." In fact I find it extremely presumptious that you presume to know the will of God. Unless it has been expressly forbidden in the Bible (which smoking hasn't) than I consider it a matter of personal preferance. And don't tell me that smoking wasn't around in the time of Christ because the smoking of shisha has been a ancient mideastern tradition.
So...I'm really curious to know why Christians who aren't American or who don't reside in the midwest are somehow exempt from this conviction you speak of?
Beyond that, and back to health, which I presume currently to be your only reason for concluding that smoking is so irrefutably damnable. -By claiming this, you are ineluctably saying that anything which causes "health issues" is sinful. I will now give you some leeway by allowing that you meant to imply that anything which damages one's health to some certain considerable extent must be labelled a sin. -I am curious, then, as to where exactly this standard is, how you came to possess such exclusive knowledge, and precisely how you have determined cigarette smoking (although you did start out with "smoking" in general, and now it is somewhat unclear as to what you are condemning) to fall beyond it?
I could and will add that most of the stuff you hear about the health risks of smoking is propaganda. And before anyone starts turning any shades of purple at that--what I mean is simply that the anti-tobacco movement tends to overexaggerate its dangers. Which necessarily leaves that there are, in fact, dangers, and I do not nearly mean to simply dismiss them as inconsequential. -It is pretty well proven that tobacco smoking in excess leads to lung cancer. Keywords: in excess. And as we know, too much of anything is bad. But really, anti-smoking is as politically correct and out of proportion as global warming. The difference, of course, being that the former started with an actual existing problem. Regardless, the fact remains.
All of that to say, no, cigarettes do not provide any strictly physical health benefits; although they certainly provide some psychological ones.
Could those benefits be gotten elsewhere? Certainly. But cigarette smoking has to be somehow enjoyable; otherwise people wouldn't do it. And really, almost nothing we do does not in some way further the delapidation of our health. Any aerobic exercise is pretty hard on your musculoskeletal system as a whole. Staring at brightly lit screens, which most of us spend a considerable time doing weekly if not daily, is terrible for the eyes. And breathe anywhere within a fifty mile radius of any metropolis on this planet; you really might as well just smoke a bloody cigarette.
Should you dismiss these as incomprable, Jon mentioned the "big ones" already: food and sun exposure. Go watch "Super Size Me" and tell me that putting any of the shit Americans consume on a regular basis into our bodies is not as grave a sin as smoking (however grave of a sin smoking is or is not, mind you). And eating healthy in this country is not that hard; it requires a bit of extra effort...but according to you, not putting forth that effort is outright sinful. Then we have tanning, especially artificially, which is quite probably worse for the health than smoking. And arguably an activity undertaken for far more shallow reasons. Either way, it's another one for your blacklist.
Yes, okay...I'm finished. Just call me Tolstoy? Without the flair.
It would be good to define sin. So far, I am reading here a presumption from Jon and Heather that sins are defined by some kind of list. I am confident that Jesus did not use a list to define sin. I was taught that sin is to fall short of the glory of God. In other words, anything that is incongruous to the nature and character of God is offensive to Him. God's desire for us is to live in all the fullness of the goodness of His presence and His character. But it isn't just existential. He has created a world in which we are rewarded for choosing good things and experience negative consequences when we delve into things that are out of keeping with what God has for us. What do you think of this? Pragmatically, could you define sin as behaviors that result in negative consequences? That is on the presumption that God is the author of the system of consequences that is built into human and physical life. Moving on to scripture. What do you do with "your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit." And "you are not your own, you have been bought with a price. Therefore, honor God with your body." I am sorry, but I can't help to chuckle at some of the above logic. When people get upset their minds fly in crazy directions. Why is smoking less of sin because people overeat? Isaac never said overeating was NOT a sin. He never said staying in the sun too long, when you know it is bad for you, was NOT a sin. They are all abuses to this wonderful body God designed for us. I think sin needs to be viewed as something we stay away from in order to experience the good He has for us rather than defined as limitations placed on us because He has the right to do so.
First of all, good job anonymous. You have a very strong argument with very good biblical backing. That is always good to see as it can be rare. My personal stance however is just a little different though. I do not believe that in itself smoking = sin, but more to the extent of smoking +? = Sin. For one example let’s use a peace pipe. This ritual often used to end wars among different tribes of Native Americans and many others I do not consider a sin in itself. However there are many parts of smoking that make it very hard not to be a sin.
Example 1: Smoking+ breaking the law= sin
If you are under 18, signed of covenant ( e.g. Bethel’s), or for some other reason are not legally allowed to smoke then yes, it is a sin.
Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. Romans 13:1
Whether you like the decisions of these authorities is irrelevant. Unless they are contradicting the word of God we are to “Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s” which includes our obedience . Disobeying these authorities is a sin.
Example 2 Smoking+ causing others to stumble = sin
I’m sorry to say that this one isn’t taken into account nearly as often as it should be. There may be many, many people out there who are not addicted and are not convicted by the holy spirit to not do it (sins involving these two will be covered later). However they may be causing other people who could easily become addicted to become so or cause them to drop their own convictions because of it, then it is indeed a sin.
So then, about eating food sacrificed to idols: We know that an idol is nothing at all in the world and that there is no God but one. 5For even if there are so-called gods, whether in heaven or on earth (as indeed there are many "gods" and many "lords"), 6yet for us there is but one God, the Father, from whom all things came and for whom we live; and there is but one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom all things came and through whom we live. 7But not everyone knows this. Some people are still so accustomed to idols that when they eat such food they think of it as having been sacrificed to an idol, and since their conscience is weak, it is defiled. 8But food does not bring us near to God; we are no worse if we do not eat, and no better if we do. 9Be careful, however, that the exercise of your freedom does not become a stumbling block to the weak. 10For if anyone with a weak conscience sees you who have this knowledge eating in an idol's temple, won't he be emboldened to eat what has been sacrificed to idols? 11So this weak brother, for whom Christ died, is destroyed by your knowledge. 12When you sin against your brothers in this way and wound their weak conscience, you sin against Christ. 13Therefore, if what I eat causes my brother to fall into sin, I will never eat meat again, so that I will not cause him to fall. (1 Corinthians 8) Here Paul informs us that not only do we sin against our brother (or sister) when we cause them to stumble, but we sin against Christ Himself! Despite the fact that eating the meat in itself is not a sin. We definitely need to be careful in this area. Even though “Everything is Permissible”(1 Cor. 10:23)(don’t take this out of context, I’m assuming all who read this are beyond that level), “Nobody should seek his own good, but the good of others” (1 Cor. 10:24) Example 3: Smoking+ addiction= Sin I’m not even going to go to deep into this one because it should be pretty self explanatory and I think everyone can agree on this one. God should be the force controlling your life, not nicotine addiction. Having it only can lead to problems Example 4: Smoking+ conviction= Sin This seems to be the main point that Isaac is getting at with his argument. In this part of the country we are told frequently the negative effects of smoking and how it can come to rule our lives. I believe this is why many Christians end up quitting after they convert. I genially think that Isaac is right in saying that there is probably at least a little conviction in most of these people’s hearts especially with verses explicitly stating that our bodies are the temple of God (thanks for bringing that point up anonymous). The final point I would like to make is that while I do not believe smoking in itself is a sin, I still think it is a really stupid idea, first of all for health reasons as have been the arguments thus far and also because you’re just flirting with temptation. 90% of people who start smoking don’t think that they could become addicted, but a lot of them generally do. I personally think that walking the line is a very dangerous thing to do. I prefer to follow Paul’s advice and “do not give the devil a foothold” (Ephesians 4:27) because it could eventually lead to sin.
Bravo Anonymous and Chris. It's so nice to argue with people who actually know how to argue.
Anonymous, for the record, I made no err in logic (nor am I upset, either)...I never said smoking was any more or less of a sin based on any other activites which may or may not be sins in themselves. I merely pointed out that there is a veritable myriad of activities which are not exactly wonderful for the health, and if smoking is a sin, so are all of those things --in Christian circles, a ridiculous stigma surrounds smoking, one of the apparently three unforgivable iniquities (the other two being alcohol consumption and premarital sex); I was merely placing it alongside things about every American does on a regular basis, such as eating terribly unhealthy food (regardless of quantity) and asserting that as far as healthy goes, they're about the same. -You make a compelling argument (I especially like your very last sentence), but I am left wondering...how far exactly do we take the purification of our body-temple thing? As I somewhat attempted to convey above, if those attempting to live for God should not ever smoke (and I know you neither explicitly contended nor concurred with this assertion one way or the other), it is inevitably also not okay to ever skydive, to ever eat a cheeseburger --or most other foods in the typical American's frequent diet--, to ever get less than eight full hours of sleep, to live in or near a city, to ever watch television...you get the idea, I hope. I'm all for living healthy, especially if it's godly. But going to extremes and isolating ourselves from anything that is potentially remotely dangerous would be ridiculous. I think it should be obvious that God doesn't mind us doing things that may have somewhat negative effects on our health in moderation. Including smoking.
Chris, I believe in essence you're mostly right. I would like to say that it's more than likely that the reason all those people become addicted to smoking is precisely that they don't think they could become addicted. This is a flat-out stupid attitude. It is literally possible to become addicted to about anything, and everyone is addicted to something; often even multiple things. Even Christ-followers must strive to put him first in their lives, above and/or in place of other pursuits which have become addictions/idols. -Once again, by your logic, people shouldn't ever do anything --but that's if it is taken to a ridiculous extreme; and otherwise, you still have a good point.
It would be beneficial for people to undertake anything which they are especially inclined towards with the knowledge that they could potentially become addicted to it --especially if it is very known to be addictive for other human types-- and thus accordingly exert the appropriate self-control in an attempt to prevent this occurance.
Oh, additionally...as far as it causing others to stumble, well...again, that applies to everything. Which, Anonymous, yes I do realize does not affect its application to smoking; the point remains. -And basically there are two sides to the equation. Smoking also has the potential to bridge the gap which tragically too often separates believers from nonbelievers. Yes, we are called to be holy; but we are also called to be in the world and not of it, and I think this is at the core of the latter call. A lot of people smoke, and smoking is frequently --even more often than not, maybe-- as social activity. A shared cigarette automatically creates common ground and a few (relative term alert) shared cigarettes could present an opportunity to discuss faith-related issues. It very nicely puts believers and nonbelievers on the same level, removing the "they think they're better than us" barrier. Disclaimer: Smoking is in no way necessary to reach unbelievers, it's only one of many hypothetical possibilities.
Finally; I must with all due respect point out that Isaac and Chris both stated their beliefs that "Christians" who smoke must surely be convicted by the Holy Spirit regarding this habit...and yet, neither of them has ever had so much as one cigarette. Ergo, they would be among the least to have any valid knowledge of the existence of such convictions. Now, because conviction is a personal matter, I have no further comments on it.
P.S. Dear Anonymous, I meant to respond to your first statement as well, just because. I completely agree with your assessment of what sin is. I was going with what Isaac had already sort of set up (as inferred). Essentially, sin is a much bigger, more complicated concept than a bunch of rules. But we must have an understanding of that concept to know how to live, and once we do, we can apply the label to certain activities which obviously fit it. Afterwhich, if one were so inclined, one could compile these newly-labelled sins into some sort of list. That is all.
People seem to have a natural inclination to make lists of do's and don'ts. There is SOME value in it. Once I have settled in my mind that something is not good for me, I don't wrestle with it anymore. I don't have to keep saying (and praying) "should I?" My mind is clear of that question and there is peace in the acceptance of that boundary. The ongoing challenge for the Christian is in: 1. Not letting a "keeping of the list" define the quality of our relationship with God. We can be cold as stone and keep the list. That is the hypocrisy that the world sees and hates. 2. We tend to put OUR lists on other people. 3. Sometimes our lists need to change.
I have never had a close friend who was at the stage of life where they smoked and it was a choice. This is a new concept to me. Everyone I know who smokes is addicted and hates the addiction.
Heather, you do need to do some research on chemical additions. Smoking has a chemical addiction that cheese burgers do not have. It is a painful reality.
Speaking as a physician, smoking tobacco is the greatest single factor in America affecting overall health. It also affects others' health (that are exposed to the second hand smoke). This is especially true for young kids with asthmatic tendencies. It increases their rate of upper respiratory infections, ear infections, pneumonia and hospitalization rates. It also has a profound effect upon a developing fetus causing preterm labor and smaller birth weights. It also makes one appear to age faster as it reduces the subcutaneous fat in the skin, mimicking aging. As you get older, lung disease, cancers of the lung, bladder, mouth, throat, esophagus and others are all much more common in smokers. It also greatly increases the risk of peripheral vascular disease and heart disease. So, there is good reason to not smoke. Also, it is very addictive, and it causes a long term addiction in which many patients can quit and start smoking again 10 years later. In a real sense, it is like a curse that you can carry with you the rest of your life. That is why, from a secular view point, I would never start smoking and would counsel anyone to stop who is currently smoking. The Biblical understanding of treating your body as God's Temple clearly would include concerns about smoking at all. It also would include many of the other habits that we Americans do that are not healthy. However, God is about relationships. Relationships are always more important than our views on such things as smoking. The question isn't so much should I smoke, but what should I do to please my Father? My need for personal libery should never trump the need to please our Father. We were created for God's pleasure, and to serve one another. We were not created to be able to express our personal freedoms at the risk of others or ourselves.
The last thing I want to do is take away from what anonymous has written. I think those are excellent posts, and I wholeheartedly agree with them.
However, someone requested that I say what I personal believe.
I think that smoking does not equal sin. However, just because it isn't an outright "sin" doesn't let us off the hook. There's lots of thing's in the world that aren't beneficial or necessary, but are permissible. "'Everything is permissible for me'—but not everything is beneficial. 'Everything is permissible for me'—but I will not be mastered by anything."
I will refer to these thing's as "indulgences." -(look! I'm defining my terms!) -This means we are not told specifically or generally that they are wrong, but are harmful to a point. This includes fast food, fake baking, video games, smoking, drinking alcohol, eating desserts... There is nothing inherently wrong or evil about them. They are not necessary, they are permissible.
For example: Luke Eddy plays video-games as a release. It takes his mind off thing's, he can unwind, take a load off. I think that's fine and healthy for Luke to do. Sometimes I personally get hooked on a video-game and play late into the night. Then I don't sleep enough, I don't finish tasks well, and it effects my life negatively. When I let this happen repetitively, it's a bad thing. -At times, I've put so much time into video-games that I feel convicted to stop playing. Usually it takes a 2x4 over the head to make me realize that, but it has happened.
-don't worry, this is actually going somewhere.- I think that indulgences are fine. But whenever you receive a conviction, it becomes wrong. And if you continue anyway, that is a sin.
I think some of these "indulgences" require far less responsibility than others. Chocolate cake is not the equivalent of alcohol. Eating a hamburger is not the equivalent of a cigarette.
The harm that goes into your body is not the only point, it is opening yourself up to a whole world of negative possibilities. To get back to smoking.: Why don't I do it? First of all, I have a logical conviction. I know it's bad for me. I know it's going to hurt me in the long run. I don't want to get lung cancer when my kids are 16. I also have a social conviction. First off, I don't want my car and coats to reek of smoke. Furthermore, I know that people in the Church will view me differently because I smoke. I know that some parents won't want their kids to be too influenced by me. Judging others is wrong, but that's how our world is. If I want to be a servant to other believers I need to alter my lifestyle.
I'm also convicted just by knowing myself. I know that smoking cigarettes will feel good and be an easy way to deal with stress. But I also know I would become addicted to them. If I started smoking, Satan would have his foothold right off the bat!
Finally, I have a spiritual conviction. Before I came to Bethel, I considered smoking just once or twice. I was 18, it was perfectly legal. But I knew God didn't want me to. There's been times after that when I'm offered a cigarette. Right then and there I don't feel like there's anything wrong with it. I think "eh, it's fine, right?" I don't feel this burning guilt in my stomach or anything. It feels fine. But I decided to decline. -Why? Because I hadn't been told otherwise yet. I personally think that if God has previously convicted you to stay away from something, HE WILL LET YOU KNOW if He wants you to do it. Remember Peter's dream about the pigs in a blanket? (ha.) Peter had spent his entire life abstaining from these thing's. When God wanted Peter to do otherwise, He specifically let Peter know.
I'm not saying I need to have repetitive dream sequences before I'll believe God wants me to smoke. But I believe there will be another conviction when the time comes.
Like Peter, I've spent my whole life being taught that smoking is being careless with my body. If God wants me to smoke, if He wants me to know "it's okay to smoke," ... He'll let me know. And part of that is staying attuned to the leading of the Holy Spirit. -Something I am not so good at.- But it's the truth.
So I should really wrap this up. I believe smoking is an indulgence. It is not automatically a sin to smoke a cigarette. However, it is a very, very, very risky one.
Take a look at this passage:
1st Corinthians Chapter 6: *12"Everything is permissible for me"—but not everything is beneficial. "Everything is permissible for me"—but I will not be mastered by anything. 13"Food for the stomach and the stomach for food"—but God will destroy them both. The body is not meant for sexual immorality, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. 14By his power God raised the Lord from the dead, and he will raise us also. 15Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ himself? Shall I then take the members of Christ and unite them with a prostitute? Never! 16Do you not know that he who unites himself with a prostitute is one with her in body? For it is said, "The two will become one flesh."[b] 17But he who unites himself with the Lord is one with him in spirit."
After reading that, a visual popped into my head.
If Jesus came down while I was smoking a cigarette, I don't think He'd be very happy. He'd probably tell a parable about Frank who spent his whole life addicted and felt guilty about it every day. And in the end Frank died from his addiction while his entire family watched helpless. Then I imagine Jesus looking into my eyes and speaking very clearly: "Isaac, WHY would you EVER go near that stuff? I spilled my blood for you, isn't that enough?"
I'll add a couple of thoughts as a pastor. Good job thinking through this logically. My opnion... smoking is stupid. The only people who I've ever heard disagree with that are young people just getting started into it thinking it's somehow cool. The older smokers and non-smokers I've talked to agree that it's just stupid... for a thousand reasons. If you're thinking about smoking, just remember that life's not about your temporary pleasures. God probably has some important roles for you to play witnessing to people, being a parent, etc. Seek God's kingdom first and let God satisfy you. It's only when your soul is disatisfied with God that something so stupid could actually look appealing.
14 comments:
i'm intrigued
Why?
[Directed at you, Isaac, since I am not particularly concerned with Laura's need to defend her reasons for being intrigued; I am, however, fairly certain that a claim like the one you just made requires some legitimate backing up].
Because smoking cigarettes is so overwhelmingly bad. The health issues vastly outweigh the benefits.
In the American midwest, I find it highly improbable that a Christian could escape conviction on the issue.
Ahem. Smoking is bad for your health, but so is many other things. Such as fast food and staying in the sun for too long a time. None of these you have labelled "sins." In fact I find it extremely presumptious that you presume to know the will of God. Unless it has been expressly forbidden in the Bible (which smoking hasn't) than I consider it a matter of personal preferance. And don't tell me that smoking wasn't around in the time of Christ because the smoking of shisha has been a ancient mideastern tradition.
You go Jon.
So...I'm really curious to know why Christians who aren't American or who don't reside in the midwest are somehow exempt from this conviction you speak of?
Beyond that, and back to health, which I presume currently to be your only reason for concluding that smoking is so irrefutably damnable.
-By claiming this, you are ineluctably saying that anything which causes "health issues" is sinful. I will now give you some leeway by allowing that you meant to imply that anything which damages one's health to some certain considerable extent must be labelled a sin.
-I am curious, then, as to where exactly this standard is, how you came to possess such exclusive knowledge, and precisely how you have determined cigarette smoking (although you did start out with "smoking" in general, and now it is somewhat unclear as to what you are condemning) to fall beyond it?
I could and will add that most of the stuff you hear about the health risks of smoking is propaganda. And before anyone starts turning any shades of purple at that--what I mean is simply that the anti-tobacco movement tends to overexaggerate its dangers. Which necessarily leaves that there are, in fact, dangers, and I do not nearly mean to simply dismiss them as inconsequential. -It is pretty well proven that tobacco smoking in excess leads to lung cancer. Keywords: in excess. And as we know, too much of anything is bad.
But really, anti-smoking is as politically correct and out of proportion as global warming. The difference, of course, being that the former started with an actual existing problem. Regardless, the fact remains.
All of that to say, no, cigarettes do not provide any strictly physical health benefits; although they certainly provide some psychological ones.
Could those benefits be gotten elsewhere? Certainly. But cigarette smoking has to be somehow enjoyable; otherwise people wouldn't do it. And really, almost nothing we do does not in some way further the delapidation of our health. Any aerobic exercise is pretty hard on your musculoskeletal system as a whole. Staring at brightly lit screens, which most of us spend a considerable time doing weekly if not daily, is terrible for the eyes. And breathe anywhere within a fifty mile radius of any metropolis on this planet; you really might as well just smoke a bloody cigarette.
Should you dismiss these as incomprable, Jon mentioned the "big ones" already: food and sun exposure. Go watch "Super Size Me" and tell me that putting any of the shit Americans consume on a regular basis into our bodies is not as grave a sin as smoking (however grave of a sin smoking is or is not, mind you). And eating healthy in this country is not that hard; it requires a bit of extra effort...but according to you, not putting forth that effort is outright sinful.
Then we have tanning, especially artificially, which is quite probably worse for the health than smoking. And arguably an activity undertaken for far more shallow reasons. Either way, it's another one for your blacklist.
Yes, okay...I'm finished. Just call me Tolstoy? Without the flair.
It would be good to define sin. So far, I am reading here a presumption from Jon and Heather that sins are defined by some kind of list. I am confident that Jesus did not use a list to define sin.
I was taught that sin is to fall short of the glory of God. In other words, anything that is incongruous to the nature and character of God is offensive to Him. God's desire for us is to live in all the fullness of the goodness of His presence and His character. But it isn't just existential. He has created a world in which we are rewarded for choosing good things and experience negative consequences when we delve into things that are out of keeping with what God has for us. What do you think of this? Pragmatically, could you define sin as behaviors that result in negative consequences? That is on the presumption that God is the author of the system of consequences that is built into human and physical life.
Moving on to scripture. What do you do with "your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit." And
"you are not your own, you have been bought with a price. Therefore, honor God with your body."
I am sorry, but I can't help to chuckle at some of the above logic. When people get upset their minds fly in crazy directions. Why is smoking less of sin because people overeat? Isaac never said overeating was NOT a sin. He never said staying in the sun too long, when you know it is bad for you, was NOT a sin. They are all abuses to this wonderful body God designed for us.
I think sin needs to be viewed as something we stay away from in order to experience the good He has for us rather than defined as limitations placed on us because He has the right to do so.
First of all, good job anonymous. You have a very strong argument with very good biblical backing. That is always good to see as it can be rare. My personal stance however is just a little different though. I do not believe that in itself smoking = sin, but more to the extent of smoking +? = Sin. For one example let’s use a peace pipe. This ritual often used to end wars among different tribes of Native Americans and many others I do not consider a sin in itself. However there are many parts of smoking that make it very hard not to be a sin.
Example 1: Smoking+ breaking the law= sin
If you are under 18, signed of covenant ( e.g. Bethel’s), or for some other reason are not legally allowed to smoke then yes, it is a sin.
Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established. The authorities that exist have been established by God. Romans 13:1
Whether you like the decisions of these authorities is irrelevant. Unless they are contradicting the word of God we are to “Give to Caesar what is Caesar’s” which includes our obedience . Disobeying these authorities is a sin.
Example 2 Smoking+ causing others to stumble = sin
I’m sorry to say that this one isn’t taken into account nearly as often as it should be. There may be many, many people out there who are not addicted and are not convicted by the holy spirit to not do it (sins involving these two will be covered later). However they may be causing other people who could easily become addicted to become so or cause them to drop their own convictions because of it, then it is indeed a sin.
So then, about eating food sacrificed to idols: We know that an idol is nothing at all in the world and that there is no God but one. 5For even if there are so-called gods, whether in heaven or on earth (as indeed there are many "gods" and many "lords"), 6yet for us there is but one God, the Father, from whom all things came and for whom we live; and there is but one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom all things came and through whom we live.
7But not everyone knows this. Some people are still so accustomed to idols that when they eat such food they think of it as having been sacrificed to an idol, and since their conscience is weak, it is defiled. 8But food does not bring us near to God; we are no worse if we do not eat, and no better if we do.
9Be careful, however, that the exercise of your freedom does not become a stumbling block to the weak. 10For if anyone with a weak conscience sees you who have this knowledge eating in an idol's temple, won't he be emboldened to eat what has been sacrificed to idols? 11So this weak brother, for whom Christ died, is destroyed by your knowledge. 12When you sin against your brothers in this way and wound their weak conscience, you sin against Christ. 13Therefore, if what I eat causes my brother to fall into sin, I will never eat meat again, so that I will not cause him to fall. (1 Corinthians 8)
Here Paul informs us that not only do we sin against our brother (or sister) when we cause them to stumble, but we sin against Christ Himself! Despite the fact that eating the meat in itself is not a sin. We definitely need to be careful in this area. Even though “Everything is Permissible”(1 Cor. 10:23)(don’t take this out of context, I’m assuming all who read this are beyond that level), “Nobody should seek his own good, but the good of others” (1 Cor. 10:24)
Example 3: Smoking+ addiction= Sin
I’m not even going to go to deep into this one because it should be pretty self explanatory and I think everyone can agree on this one. God should be the force controlling your life, not nicotine addiction. Having it only can lead to problems
Example 4: Smoking+ conviction= Sin
This seems to be the main point that Isaac is getting at with his argument. In this part of the country we are told frequently the negative effects of smoking and how it can come to rule our lives. I believe this is why many Christians end up quitting after they convert. I genially think that Isaac is right in saying that there is probably at least a little conviction in most of these people’s hearts especially with verses explicitly stating that our bodies are the temple of God (thanks for bringing that point up anonymous).
The final point I would like to make is that while I do not believe smoking in itself is a sin, I still think it is a really stupid idea, first of all for health reasons as have been the arguments thus far and also because you’re just flirting with temptation. 90% of people who start smoking don’t think that they could become addicted, but a lot of them generally do. I personally think that walking the line is a very dangerous thing to do. I prefer to follow Paul’s advice and “do not give the devil a foothold” (Ephesians 4:27) because it could eventually lead to sin.
very well put chris. i like your explanation.
Bravo Anonymous and Chris. It's so nice to argue with people who actually know how to argue.
Anonymous, for the record, I made no err in logic (nor am I upset, either)...I never said smoking was any more or less of a sin based on any other activites which may or may not be sins in themselves. I merely pointed out that there is a veritable myriad of activities which are not exactly wonderful for the health, and if smoking is a sin, so are all of those things --in Christian circles, a ridiculous stigma surrounds smoking, one of the apparently three unforgivable iniquities (the other two being alcohol consumption and premarital sex); I was merely placing it alongside things about every American does on a regular basis, such as eating terribly unhealthy food (regardless of quantity) and asserting that as far as healthy goes, they're about the same.
-You make a compelling argument (I especially like your very last sentence), but I am left wondering...how far exactly do we take the purification of our body-temple thing? As I somewhat attempted to convey above, if those attempting to live for God should not ever smoke (and I know you neither explicitly contended nor concurred with this assertion one way or the other), it is inevitably also not okay to ever skydive, to ever eat a cheeseburger --or most other foods in the typical American's frequent diet--, to ever get less than eight full hours of sleep, to live in or near a city, to ever watch television...you get the idea, I hope. I'm all for living healthy, especially if it's godly. But going to extremes and isolating ourselves from anything that is potentially remotely dangerous would be ridiculous. I think it should be obvious that God doesn't mind us doing things that may have somewhat negative effects on our health in moderation. Including smoking.
Chris, I believe in essence you're mostly right. I would like to say that it's more than likely that the reason all those people become addicted to smoking is precisely that they don't think they could become addicted. This is a flat-out stupid attitude. It is literally possible to become addicted to about anything, and everyone is addicted to something; often even multiple things. Even Christ-followers must strive to put him first in their lives, above and/or in place of other pursuits which have become addictions/idols.
-Once again, by your logic, people shouldn't ever do anything --but that's if it is taken to a ridiculous extreme; and otherwise, you still have a good point.
It would be beneficial for people to undertake anything which they are especially inclined towards with the knowledge that they could potentially become addicted to it --especially if it is very known to be addictive for other human types-- and thus accordingly exert the appropriate self-control in an attempt to prevent this occurance.
Oh, additionally...as far as it causing others to stumble, well...again, that applies to everything. Which, Anonymous, yes I do realize does not affect its application to smoking; the point remains.
-And basically there are two sides to the equation. Smoking also has the potential to bridge the gap which tragically too often separates believers from nonbelievers. Yes, we are called to be holy; but we are also called to be in the world and not of it, and I think this is at the core of the latter call. A lot of people smoke, and smoking is frequently --even more often than not, maybe-- as social activity. A shared cigarette automatically creates common ground and a few (relative term alert) shared cigarettes could present an opportunity to discuss faith-related issues. It very nicely puts believers and nonbelievers on the same level, removing the "they think they're better than us" barrier.
Disclaimer: Smoking is in no way necessary to reach unbelievers, it's only one of many hypothetical possibilities.
Finally; I must with all due respect point out that Isaac and Chris both stated their beliefs that "Christians" who smoke must surely be convicted by the Holy Spirit regarding this habit...and yet, neither of them has ever had so much as one cigarette. Ergo, they would be among the least to have any valid knowledge of the existence of such convictions. Now, because conviction is a personal matter, I have no further comments on it.
This concludes Volume II...
P.S.
Dear Anonymous,
I meant to respond to your first statement as well, just because. I completely agree with your assessment of what sin is. I was going with what Isaac had already sort of set up (as inferred). Essentially, sin is a much bigger, more complicated concept than a bunch of rules. But we must have an understanding of that concept to know how to live, and once we do, we can apply the label to certain activities which obviously fit it. Afterwhich, if one were so inclined, one could compile these newly-labelled sins into some sort of list. That is all.
People seem to have a natural inclination to make lists of do's and don'ts. There is SOME value in it. Once I have settled in my mind that something is not good for me, I don't wrestle with it anymore. I don't have to keep saying (and praying) "should I?" My mind is clear of that question and there is peace in the acceptance of that boundary. The ongoing challenge for the Christian is in:
1. Not letting a "keeping of the list" define the quality of our relationship with God. We can be cold as stone and keep the list. That is the hypocrisy that the world sees and hates.
2. We tend to put OUR lists on other people.
3. Sometimes our lists need to change.
I have never had a close friend who was at the stage of life where they smoked and it was a choice. This is a new concept to me. Everyone I know who smokes is addicted and hates the addiction.
Heather, you do need to do some research on chemical additions. Smoking has a chemical addiction that cheese burgers do not have. It is a painful reality.
Speaking as a physician, smoking tobacco is the greatest single factor in America affecting overall health. It also affects others' health (that are exposed to the second hand smoke). This is especially true for young kids with asthmatic tendencies. It increases their rate of upper respiratory infections, ear infections, pneumonia and hospitalization rates. It also has a profound effect upon a developing fetus causing preterm labor and smaller birth weights. It also makes one appear to age faster as it reduces the subcutaneous fat in the skin, mimicking aging. As you get older, lung disease, cancers of the lung, bladder, mouth, throat, esophagus and others are all much more common in smokers. It also greatly increases the risk of peripheral vascular disease and heart disease. So, there is good reason to not smoke. Also, it is very addictive, and it causes a long term addiction in which many patients can quit and start smoking again 10 years later. In a real sense, it is like a curse that you can carry with you the rest of your life. That is why, from a secular view point, I would never start smoking and would counsel anyone to stop who is currently smoking. The Biblical understanding of treating your body as God's Temple clearly would include concerns about smoking at all. It also would include many of the other habits that we Americans do that are not healthy. However, God is about relationships. Relationships are always more important than our views on such things as smoking. The question isn't so much should I smoke, but what should I do to please my Father? My need for personal libery should never trump the need to please our Father. We were created for God's pleasure, and to serve one another. We were not created to be able to express our personal freedoms at the risk of others or ourselves.
The last thing I want to do is take away from what anonymous has written. I think those are excellent posts, and I wholeheartedly agree with them.
However, someone requested that I say what I personal believe.
I think that smoking does not equal sin. However, just because it isn't an outright "sin" doesn't let us off the hook.
There's lots of thing's in the world that aren't beneficial or necessary, but are permissible.
"'Everything is permissible for me'—but not everything is beneficial. 'Everything is permissible for me'—but I will not be mastered by anything."
I will refer to these thing's as "indulgences." -(look! I'm defining my terms!) -This means we are not told specifically or generally that they are wrong, but are harmful to a point. This includes fast food, fake baking, video games, smoking, drinking alcohol, eating desserts...
There is nothing inherently wrong or evil about them. They are not necessary, they are permissible.
For example: Luke Eddy plays video-games as a release. It takes his mind off thing's, he can unwind, take a load off. I think that's fine and healthy for Luke to do.
Sometimes I personally get hooked on a video-game and play late into the night. Then I don't sleep enough, I don't finish tasks well, and it effects my life negatively. When I let this happen repetitively, it's a bad thing.
-At times, I've put so much time into video-games that I feel convicted to stop playing. Usually it takes a 2x4 over the head to make me realize that, but it has happened.
-don't worry, this is actually going somewhere.-
I think that indulgences are fine.
But whenever you receive a conviction, it becomes wrong. And if you continue anyway, that is a sin.
I think some of these "indulgences" require far less responsibility than others. Chocolate cake is not the equivalent of alcohol. Eating a hamburger is not the equivalent of a cigarette.
The harm that goes into your body is not the only point, it is opening yourself up to a whole world of negative possibilities.
To get back to smoking.: Why don't I do it?
First of all, I have a logical conviction. I know it's bad for me. I know it's going to hurt me in the long run. I don't want to get lung cancer when my kids are 16.
I also have a social conviction. First off, I don't want my car and coats to reek of smoke. Furthermore, I know that people in the Church will view me differently because I smoke. I know that some parents won't want their kids to be too influenced by me.
Judging others is wrong, but that's how our world is. If I want to be a servant to other believers I need to alter my lifestyle.
I'm also convicted just by knowing myself. I know that smoking cigarettes will feel good and be an easy way to deal with stress. But I also know I would become addicted to them. If I started smoking, Satan would have his foothold right off the bat!
Finally, I have a spiritual conviction. Before I came to Bethel, I considered smoking just once or twice. I was 18, it was perfectly legal. But I knew God didn't want me to.
There's been times after that when I'm offered a cigarette. Right then and there I don't feel like there's anything wrong with it. I think "eh, it's fine, right?" I don't feel this burning guilt in my stomach or anything. It feels fine.
But I decided to decline. -Why? Because I hadn't been told otherwise yet.
I personally think that if God has previously convicted you to stay away from something, HE WILL LET YOU KNOW if He wants you to do it.
Remember Peter's dream about the pigs in a blanket? (ha.) Peter had spent his entire life abstaining from these thing's. When God wanted Peter to do otherwise, He specifically let Peter know.
I'm not saying I need to have repetitive dream sequences before I'll believe God wants me to smoke. But I believe there will be another conviction when the time comes.
Like Peter, I've spent my whole life being taught that smoking is being careless with my body. If God wants me to smoke, if He wants me to know "it's okay to smoke,"
... He'll let me know.
And part of that is staying attuned to the leading of the Holy Spirit. -Something I am not so good at.- But it's the truth.
So I should really wrap this up.
I believe smoking is an indulgence. It is not automatically a sin to smoke a cigarette. However, it is a very, very, very risky one.
Take a look at this passage:
1st Corinthians Chapter 6:
*12"Everything is permissible for me"—but not everything is beneficial. "Everything is permissible for me"—but I will not be mastered by anything. 13"Food for the stomach and the stomach for food"—but God will destroy them both. The body is not meant for sexual immorality, but for the Lord, and the Lord for the body. 14By his power God raised the Lord from the dead, and he will raise us also. 15Do you not know that your bodies are members of Christ himself? Shall I then take the members of Christ and unite them with a prostitute? Never! 16Do you not know that he who unites himself with a prostitute is one with her in body? For it is said, "The two will become one flesh."[b] 17But he who unites himself with the Lord is one with him in spirit."
After reading that, a visual popped into my head.
If Jesus came down while I was smoking a cigarette, I don't think He'd be very happy. He'd probably tell a parable about Frank who spent his whole life addicted and felt guilty about it every day. And in the end Frank died from his addiction while his entire family watched helpless.
Then I imagine Jesus looking into my eyes and speaking very clearly: "Isaac, WHY would you EVER go near that stuff? I spilled my blood for you, isn't that enough?"
I'll add a couple of thoughts as a pastor. Good job thinking through this logically.
My opnion... smoking is stupid. The only people who I've ever heard disagree with that are young people just getting started into it thinking it's somehow cool. The older smokers and non-smokers I've talked to agree that it's just stupid... for a thousand reasons. If you're thinking about smoking, just remember that life's not about your temporary pleasures. God probably has some important roles for you to play witnessing to people, being a parent, etc. Seek God's kingdom first and let God satisfy you. It's only when your soul is disatisfied with God that something so stupid could actually look appealing.
Post a Comment