
4.5/5 stars
No spoilers, but might reveal overall themes of the film.
I can't quite sum up all my thoughts of this, so I'll divide this up into sections:
Prevailing thought: Good movie, but the Graphic Novel is better. Get your hands on it.
Beautiful visuals, sweeping story, a very good adaptation to the big screen for one of the most beloved Graphic Novels of all time. Everything was handled well, though some things better than others, and the end result was a great film. Dark, depraved, yet somehow heroic, this critique of the Superhero finally hit the big screen. Congrats everyone.

CONTENT NOTE: I was blown away by how *intense* the adult material in Watchmen was handled. The book has violence, sex, and depravity, it needs to be there to tell the story. But wow. Think 300 without the swords, bone crunching instead of blood spraying. Not to mention that Dr. Manhattan (big blue guy) spends most of the movie nude, and the camera doesn't always shoot to obscure his reproductive organs. This is done to show how Dr. Manhattan has lost touch with his humanity, and not in a sexual way whatsoever. However, he is still naked. But also blue. Something about him being blue is somehow less offensive to the senses. It's kind of like a big, blue, Michelangelo's David statue walking around. Though considering the amount of violence, crime, depravity, a near rape, and one very intense sex-scene, the occasional naked blue man isn't so bad. Definitely a film for adults.

The action was intense and really drew me into the movie. You're not quite sure who to root for sometimes, but then the punches start flying and I'm all "YEAH!" Although, some moments that I had devoted very high emotion to in the comic, (the opening murder of the Comedian, the funeral, a particular segment on the planet Mars,) had very touching memories for me. To see them interpreted in a different way left me saying "eh, I prefer my own imagination, thanks."
That's kind of how I felt about the soundtrack too. I loved it, great choice of songs, very cool. But the first viewing of Watchmen left me a little jarred, hearing stuff like Simon & Garfunkle or Ride of the Valkyries. Thinking "hey, I know this song!" drew me out of the movie rather than brought me deeper into it. May be solved with multiple viewings.
Character development felt a bit rushed, especially Laurie. Laurie always seemed the most 2-dimensional of the otherwise complicated Watchmen cast. But wow, scrunching the character interaction into a 2.5hr movie really didn't go so hot for the Silver Spectre's dialog. Oh well, just more appreciation for the Graphic Novel I guess. Several things in general were just different than I had imagined them, which made it slightly less enjoyable for me personally. But hey, everyone reads differently, right?

Now to stop complaining and actually convince you that I liked it: I really liked Rorschach, Nite Owl, and the Comedian. Dr. Manhattan was probably handled about as well as one could film a super-complicated character like him. (existing in multiple times? How do you portray that in a movie!?) And Laurie had her butt-kicking moments too. Rorschach, one of the top comic characters of all time, was handled brilliantly and came across well. You felt sympathy for the Comedian. Nite Owl had a shining moment of strength in his mini-speech towards the end. This was strength the comic's Nite Owl never quite gave us, but the film did. (probably the result of having to cut Tales of the Black Frigate from the story.)
And finally, something about the ending, (slightly adapted from the comic,) just didn't bring it all together for me. I felt like the movie did not lead up to that point, as if there was this cool-sexy-action-fast-pace plot, and then this "oh yeah, nuclear war" plot that was totally separate. However my friends are convinced that this was a good ending for the movie. Perhaps it deserves a second viewing, because it *is* just a movie. I think very highly of The Watchmen, and perhaps after seeing the film I have realized just what a special piece of literature that book truly is. Where LotR felt like the perfect translation of book to film, Watchmen left a few disappointed kernels in my heart.
Sorry Zack Snyder, you did the near impossible, everybody said Watchmen could never be made into a movie and you finally succeeded. But I wasn't 100% with it. Perhaps you'll get me with that Director's Cut.
3 comments:
to be fair, Snyder did far better than I was expecting.
Yes... to add a disclaimer... Most of my complaints will probably be settled by watching the film for a second time. I just disagreed with a lot of interpretations, but that's part of seeing a movie. Sure it's not *my* movie, it's not the way *I* would do it, but most movies aren't done the way I want anyway.
Either way, it made me appreciate the Graphic Novel even more, which I started reading again.
"....be in bed by ten..."
Post a Comment